I mean if you’ve read the first three you’re going to read this one too but it made me wonder if her contract with her publisher required a book before it was ready? It’s obviously setting up for the next book and I suppose it was like a nice relaxing cup of tea compared to the first three but don’t expect the sun, the moon and the stars.

After the other books this one really let me down. I was addicted to these books then I read this one and was just super bored. It’s also incredibly short.

Tone completely shifted with this book. I enjoyed parts of it but it felt like massive portions of character development were left incomplete and the ending seemed extremely rushed and unnatural.

Seems like this could have been condensed to a chapter or two in the final book in the series rather than it being a stand alone book on its own. Frankly disappointing that it was a separate book, particularly when it cost almost as much as the others, and yet extremely short! Felt like a way to get people who wanted to read the whole series to spend more money.

Fun, but not the same as the rest of the series.

Yeah I should have definitely skipped this book. Massive let down compared to other books in the series. I understand the aim of character building up but this book was a complete snooze fest.

Great, but an unnecessary break in tone. I majorly enjoy parts of it, but often found myself rushing to get back to the characters and storylines I cared about. It didn’t feel essential, but I’d still recommend it to fans of the series.

Boring. So so boring. I ended up just looking up summaries because I could not get myself to finish. And it’s a small book… I’m obsessed with the other books, but this one was definitely unnecessary. Had to skip.

I liked that there wasn’t a lot of battling going on in this book. It helped add more of a story line to everyone on who they really were.

I loved the POV of each character. I love her writing so much. 4th book in and I am waiting to see what the Sarah does in the next book. Please don’t break my heart girl I have so much more to read from you.